Hilary Duff, a Disney actress, and Mike Comrie, a former professional hockey player, began dating in 2007 and had a fast-paced courtship. They became engaged in February 2010 and married in August 2010 in a top-secret, ultra-romantic candlelit evening ceremony. Despite their picture-perfect nuptials at the San Ysidro Ranch in Santa Barbara, California (the same spot where JFK honeymooned with Jackie O, according to Marie Claire), their marriage was far from flawless.
In March 2012, the young lovebirds welcomed their first child, son Luca Cruz, into the world, but something went wrong soon after. In January 2013, the couple put the brakes on their happily ever after when a controversy made national headlines.
In January 2016, the couple announced their divorce. So, what happened, and why did they split up so soon after their amazing wedding? Here’s why Hilary Duff and Mike Comrie couldn’t make their relationship work.
Why Was Hilary Duff’s Marriage To Mike Comrie So Exhausting?
In a 2015 interview with Cosmopolitan, the former Lizzie Mcguire star discussed some of the underlying issues that led to her divorce from Comrie, including their fading romance. “When Mike and I met, we were tremendously in love,” she told the magazine, but that soon changed. “I don’t want to come across as bitter, but I’m not sure if people are supposed to be together forever,” she explained. Over the course of a lengthy relationship, things happen that you can’t always avoid “She was adamant. “A 20-year marriage must be a wonderful accomplishment, but there must also be significant sacrifices. I really want to fight for happiness all of the time.”
Duff alluded to a difficult lesson she may have learned first-hand during her marriage to Comrie during an interview with Younger co-star Nico Tortorella on his podcast, The Love Bomb: “Marriage requires effort. Marriage is quite difficult “she declared. “I understand boredom or not connecting after however many years of marriage or a relationship […] that’s where the work comes in,” Duff said later when asked if she still believes in monogamy. Isn’t that a lot of lip service paid to “hard work”? Was it a wedding or a roofing project?
Is Hilary Duff And Mike Comrie Too Young To Marry?
While speaking candidly about her divorce for her Cosmopolitan cover story in 2015, Duff intimated that the couple may have just been too young to marry. “I’d been working since I was 11 or 12, so making that decision at such a young age seemed natural for me,” she explained, “but maybe it wasn’t.” She was quick to state, however, that she has no regrets. She went on to say, “We spent the majority of our time together really happy.” “It wasn’t working out well enough for us to stay together, but there was still a lot of love.”
When the actress appeared on The Talk the following year, she was even more sure that age had played a role in her divorce. She didn’t play coy when one of the hosts questioned, “Do you think you were too young when you were married?” When she responded, the then-29-year-old didn’t mince words “I do. When I married, I was 22 years old. I’m now divorced with a four-year-old daughter.” “I wouldn’t alter a thing,” she continued, “but I don’t think we were mature enough to stick it out.”
Hilary Duff Divorce Finalized With Mike Comrie
Hilary Duff made the breakup official and filed for divorce on February 20, 2015, just one day after the Daily Mail piece went public, following her husband’s aforementioned tabloid controversy. The timing, according to one insider who talked with TMZ, was not coincidental. Duff cited their date of separation as January 2013, citing irreconcilable differences, and requested primary custody of Luca because she was concerned that Comrie’s partying might harm their little son.
They finally reached an agreement in January 2016, three years after their initial split, and despite Duff’s demands, they agreed to share custody of Luca. The actress retains the couple’s two houses, according to divorce papers acquired by TMZ: a Beverly Hills mansion and a Malibu mobile home, which we’re betting isn’t your standard trailer. Comrie, on the other hand, went away with a “2014 Bentley coupe, a 2013 Mercedes G-Class SUV, and a pile of jewels.”
While a prenuptial agreement promised that the couple would “share child-rearing expenditures and neither receives spousal maintenance,” Duff was forced to pay her ex-husband $2,408,786, or half the value of their Beverly Hills property.